It took over a year, but the Apple TV finally had a worthwhile competitor, the Netflix Player by Roku Digital. I’ve been using the Apple TV since day one and the Netflix Player for only two weeks, but I can already see the real differences and for the most part Apple TV is the clear winner.
1) The Interface: Here’s its Apple TV all the way. Since the Apple TV 2.0 refresh, the Apple TV is a pleasure to use and you can rent and buy TV episodes and movies while never leaving your couch. The one problem is that there’s still little rhyme or reason to which ones you can rent and which ones you can buy and until you’re actually looking at a title’s information, you can’t tell which is which.
The phrase ‘bare-bones’ was made for the Netflix Player’s interface. With it, you can watch movies and TV shows from the Netflix library and you can fast-forward or reverse—no chapters here—and that’s about it.
Before you can watch anything on your Netflix Player you need to queue it up from your Netflix account on your PC. Some writers have been reporting that you don’t need a PC to run Netflix Player. That’s not true. Netflix states that you “must have a computer running Windows XP with Service Pack 2 or higher, or Windows Vista; Internet Explorer version 6 or higher; Windows Media Player version 11 or higher; an active broadband connection to the Internet; 1GHz processor; 512MBs of RAM; and 3GBs of free hard disk” space to use it. Mac users appear to be out of luck.
With Apple TV, you only need any PC that can run iTunes. Advantage: Apple.